If you have dark circles, this transfer-proof eyeliner is your new holy grail. (2023)

Eyeliner can create amazing definition, but covering the eyeliner can present some unique challenges: Namely, it tends not to stay in place and it can be difficult to create a line that's visible when the eye is opened. That being said, a little tweaking in your makeup bag may do the trick. Whether you choose liquid, gel or eyeliner, the best cover-up eyeliners have a waterproof and smudge-resistant formula that resists transfer all day.


Melanie Barrese is the main makeup artistLondon eye makeup brand Eyeko, focusing on natural ingredients for long-lasting formulas.

susie gerstein is aNew York City Celebrity Makeup ArtistsHe has worked with clients such as Karlie Kloss, Leighton Meester, and Millie Bobby Brown.

What is the best eyeliner?

According to makeup artist Melanie Barrese,typeThe amount of eyeliner isn't as important as finding a long-lasting, smudge-proof formula. "Usually you can use a liquid or a pencil, but it is better to chooseLong-lasting waterproof formula, so it doesn't transfer to the lid and [prevents] the liner from shifting throughout the day. "

However, if Barrese had to choose between pencil and liquid eyeliner, she would recommend pencil eyeliners because they are "softer, easier to wear, and can be used for defined liner and eyeliner."smoky lookAlso keep in mind that traditional eyeliner generally creates a more subtle look, while gel pencil and liquid eyeliner offer more pigment and intensity.

Lastly, keep in mind that liquid formulas are the best liner for wings and may haveeither felt tipor brush head. Felt tip for easy application (Perfect if you are new to(like using a fountain pen), while the brush tip will allow you to create super thin and thick lines, although it may take some practice.

How to apply eyeliner on masked eyes

The application can also be a bit tricky for covered eyes. While your instinct may be to close your eyes while applying your eyeliner, you may actually get a more accurate view by looking straight ahead. New York-based makeup artist Suzy Gerstein explains, "I recommend that those with covered eyes look directly into the mirror when applying their eyeliner to get the right angle and gauge what they're actually seeing when they open their eyes."

Other Eyeliner Tips for Covering Your Eyes

  • Thick eyeliner can take up a lot of space on a droopy eyelid. If you want more room to show eyeshadow, hold the liner closer to the lash line or apply to the waterline (this can be done by gently lifting the upper lid and drawing the liner over the lashes).
  • For lifted eye makeup, gradually increase the thickness of the liner as you move towards the outer corner of the eye.
  • To frame your eyes without looking heavy, opt for a color other than black, such as brown, dark gray, or purple.

With all that in mind, I've rounded up the best eyeliners to cover your eyes, from creamy gel formulas to ultra-rich liquid options. The liner you choose will depend on how you like to apply it and the look you want.

Buy the best eyeliners for closed eyes

hurry? These are the best eyeliners to cover the eyes:

  1. Basic pencil liner:no budget elf retractable eyeliner
  2. Gel pens with intense pigments:Rimmel Rimmel Scandaleyes Gel Eyeliner
  3. Felt tip liquid eyeliner for easy application:Eyeko Slim Liquid Eyeliner
  4. Matte Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner: NYX Epic Ink Eyeliner
  5. Cons of Satin Brush Liquid Eyeliner:Maybelline super easy liquid pencil
  6. Quick-drying gel eyeliner in over 25 shades:Inglot AMC Gel Eyeliner

1.Basic Pencil Eyeliner: Elf Retractable Eyeliner No Budget

to emphasize:

  • Creamy, smudge-proof formula
  • Retractable tip stays sharp
  • payable price

If you're looking for versatility to create subtle or smoky eyeliner looks, thiself pencilis your best option. The retractable design keeps the tip sharp over time, allowing you to line the lids with a fine line or blend them out. Highly pigmented and waterproof, this creamy formula can be applied to the lash line, waterline, or even as an eyeshadow all over the lid. Not to mention, it's super affordable, so you can even buy two: one to keep around the house and one to keep in your tote bag.

According to critics:"I love this eyeliner!! It doesn't smudge or fade. I have to use the eye drops several times a day and it even stays put. In fact, the tube has lasted me a long time. Here's what use to make money Best value ever, even better than a pencil More visual impact, lasts longer Highly recommend!!"

  • Available shades: 3

2. Intense Color Gel Pens: Rimmel Scandaleyes

to emphasize:

  • Gel formula spreads easily
  • The pigments are more intense than traditional pencil formulas.
  • payable price

rimmelgel eyelinerIt glides on easily, locks in place, lasts up to 24 hours, and the ultra-fine pen tip lets you draw precise lines around the waterline. The waterproof formula is also enhanced with Powder Eye Shadow, a pigment-boosting ingredient for intense color. With over 16,000 five-star ratings on Amazon, this affordable eyeliner comes in a variety of dynamic shades of black, brown, navy, and beige.

According to critics:"Rimmel Scandeleyes are just the right consistency for gel pens. They're not too wet or too dry and can easily draw thick or thin lines depending on the angle of the gel tip. Unlike dry formulas, the intensity of the color is very high and lasts all day someone with thick, droopy eyelids usually liquid eyeliner is the only thing i can use that doesn't bleed or migrate to my lids [...] if i'm near the lash line Use an eyelid primer and this Rimmel brand eyeliner stays man, no flaking or smudging…”

  • Available shades: 6

3.Felt tip liquid eyeliner for easy application: Eyeko Skinny Liquid Eyeliner

Expert Picks

to emphasize:

  • Felt tips are easy to use
  • matte black finish
  • Conditions eyelids with algae extract

Barrese recommends Eyeko'sliquid eyelinerIdeal for lining the eyes as the fine felt tip creates ultra-precise lines along the lash line and waterline. The long-lasting anti-blemish formula contains seaweed extract to condition the delicate skin of the eyelid. Dries quickly to a matte charcoal black finish that resists smearing and transfer. While the brand doesn't say if the product is completely waterproof, some reviewers have noted that it holds up to light moisture.

According to critics:"The tip is very sharp when applied and feels stiff, not like a brush...more like a marker, takes some getting used to but worth it for the staying power! I have oily lids with lids and it works everything ends if necessary. The day stays in place and even stays that way until the next morning. I love it."

  • Available tones: 1

4 ofMatte Brush Liquid Eyeliner: NYX Epic Ink Liner

to emphasize:

  • Flexible brush head for ultra-fine and thick lines
  • matte black finish
  • Over 46,000 5-star Amazon reviews

This is aliquid eyelinerIt's a favorite among beauty junkies—it has an overall 4.5-star rating after thousands of reviews. NYX's smudge-resistant formula dries to a matte black finish that lasts all day. Since it's also waterproof, you won't have to worry about streaking if you get it in your eyes. The multi-purpose brush head can draw anything from fine lines to thick pens - the more pressure you apply to the brush, the thicker the lines will be.

According to critics:"This is the best long-wearing, smudge-proof eyeliner! I have two things that work against me, oily skin and heavy lids, so eyeliner never lasts on me, but this is it." best I've tried. Ok. The tip is also thin and doesn't warp. Buy it!"

  • Available shades:2

5.Satin Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner: Maybelline Super Easy Liquid Pencil

to emphasize:

  • Flexible brush head for ultra-fine and thick lines
  • satin finish
  • easy grip ballpoint pen

Designed with a flexible brush head that won't skip or drag,liquid eyelinerGreat for defining covered eyes, you can easily create thin and thick lines (although it may take some practice). The waterproof formula lasts up to 24 hours and dries to a satin finish with a silky shine. The hex barrel gives you a firmer grip for smoother lines. More than 35,000 reviewers have given this eyeliner a perfect five-star rating on Amazon, with many praising its long-lasting formula, which can withstand even rainy days.

According to critics:"Great for covering lids. The first non-drip eyeliner. I've tried many waterproof pencils, gels, brushes, and pointed eyeliners. When wet, raining, or at work, this one doesn't drip. [...] Amazingly, the eyeliner lasts a long time, 10+ hours, and doesn't smudge. It works for me!"

  • Available shades:2

6. Gel Eyeliner in Over 25 Colors: Inglot AMC Gel Eyeliner

to emphasize:

  • Dries in 60 seconds.
  • The matte gel formula lasts all day.
  • Available in a variety of colors

It isgel eyelinerInglot's product dries to a matte finish in just one minute and stays there all day. Available in over two dozen shades, from purple to teal to red, the creamy formula is perfect for creating one-of-a-kind looks. Unlike pencil or liquid eyeliner, this eyeliner comes in a small bottle and is applied with a fine, angled pen.wire brush(not included). The lighter shade can even be used all over the lid as a long-wearing, opaque eyeshadow.

According to critics:"The buzz surrounding this product is well deserved. I bought the white shade and it is very opaque and smooth. Even after hearing so many great reviews, I am still skeptical about this product on my water line and my heavily covered, oily skin Surprised by the durability of my upper eyelid."

  • Available tones: 26

Also great: an eyeshadow primer that sets your makeup.

To further prevent makeup transfer, prep your eyelids with good tools.eyelid primer——This product has been well received by blindfolded users and the price is also very affordable. The non-greasy formula creates a smooth base, and the addition of shea butter adds just the right amount of moisture.

According to critics:"I've been using this eyeshadow primer for a long time and I love it. You only use a little and the eyeshadow stays on all day and the tube lasts forever. It's a game changer for me since I have the blindfolded and "My eyeliner always runs all the way to my eyelids, my shadow doesn't stay put. Excellent product, especially for the price!"


Melanie Barres, Head Makeup Artist Eyeko

Suzy Gerstein, celebrity makeup artist


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Greg Kuvalis

Last Updated: 21/04/2023

Views: 6125

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg Kuvalis

Birthday: 1996-12-20

Address: 53157 Trantow Inlet, Townemouth, FL 92564-0267

Phone: +68218650356656

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Knitting, Amateur radio, Skiing, Running, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Greg Kuvalis, I am a witty, spotless, beautiful, charming, delightful, thankful, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.